I do not know how to explain my feeling towards Freud. He is
absolutely insane, there is no doubt about that, but that does not mean there
is no truth behind what he has learned and taught about psychoanalysis. The
first example of how I can see a relation between Freud’s beliefs and myself is
the Oedipus complex. Before you make any rash assumption, I do not want to kill
my mother nor do I want to marry my dad. This being said, I do have the most
problems with my mom and a great relationship with my dad. This holds true for
a lot of girls my age, and it no way means I want to end her life, whatsoever. Also,
I find striking similarities between my current boyfriend and my dad. I was not
initially attracted to him because he was like my father, these are just things
I notices as are relationship continued. For example, both cannot hold a phone
conversation, exhibit horrible road rage, and are very protective. Are these
things I look for in a man? No, but still the two male figures in my life have
these characteristics.
The biggest problem I struggled with while reading Freud’s
Lectures was his interpretation of dreams. This is a topic in which I, in no
way, agree with him. Freud believes our dreams are “unconscious wishful
impulses” which we cannot have in real life, and therefore obtain in our sleep.
This struck a personal chord with me, because I am plagued with bad dreams.
Being a freshman in college, it was a big change moving out and away from my
parents. Even now, in my spring semester, I am still haunted by dreams of my
family at home being hurt by an intruder and there is nothing I can do. I have
to watch as the gruesome acts take place against my beloved parents. This keeps
me from sleeping many nights. Is Freud trying to say that somewhere tucked in
my unconscious I want my parents to be murdered? That is absurd. He completely
disregards nightmares in all of his lectures on dreaming, which makes him an
unreliable source of information on the topic.
I see a lot of truth
behind Freud’s analysis of children. He talks about them as sexual beings,
which turns many people off. It is understood that children are not capable of
having sex, he uses this term very lightly. Children go through phases in which
they learn by pleasure and exploration of themselves. Many of Freud’s patients’
problems can be rooted back to their childhood. Of all of his research, the
most evidence supports this topic and it is, in some twisted way, logical. It
is common knowledge that we are the most impressionable on at an early age, and
the basic skills stay with us an entire lives. If a baby is deprived from being
breast fed, they may yearn for sucking (or any action of the mouth) in their
adult life – such as smoking cigarettes. In the phallic stage, children explore
their body, which includes their genitalia. I am sure no one likes to see that
little boy out shopping with his mom with his hand awkwardly in his pants, but
this is part of maturing and needed, within a certain extent, to develop
properly.
Hi Ally,
ReplyDeleteI think it's very possible that Freud (and others interested in his mode of dream interpretation) would see your dreams as more richly symbolic--thus not nes. directly indicating a desire to see your family hurt. But rather a desire to make a break--or not to make a break, resulting in conflicting impulses in your unconscious mind! Interesting that you embrace Freud except when it comes to your dreams!